DPP v Kirtley [2012] VSC 78: the two essential elements of speeding

There are two essential ingredients to a charge of speeding in Victoria (and, therefore, probably across Australia):(1) the driving of a motor vehicle; and (2) in excess of the speed limit.More information might be nice, but it's not essential. There are more things that the prosecution are required to prove an offence under Road Rule …

Continue reading DPP v Kirtley [2012] VSC 78: the two essential elements of speeding

Slaveski v Smith & Anor [2012] VSCA 25: the right to representation

There is a right to representation as part of an accused's overarching right to a fair criminal trial, but it's rarely going to give rise to an enforceable remedy. (And what is a right without a remedy?) When faced with the unavoidable prospect of an unfair trial, a trial court should not order unwilling representation …

Continue reading Slaveski v Smith & Anor [2012] VSCA 25: the right to representation

Slaveski v Smith & Anor [2012] VSCA 25: the right to representation

There is a right to representation as part of an accused's overarching right to a fair criminal trial, but it's rarely going to give rise to an enforceable remedy. (And what is a right without a remedy?) When faced with the unavoidable prospect of an unfair trial, a trial court should not order unwilling representation …

Continue reading Slaveski v Smith & Anor [2012] VSCA 25: the right to representation