Victoria is the last jurisdiction where an offender can appeal a decision of the Magistrates' Court to a court of intermediate appeal — here, the County Court — and the appeal is conducted as a rehearing (aka de novo appeal) rather than in the strict sense of an appeal which is a consideration of the …
Continue reading Repeal of de novo appeals deferred to 2025?
DPP v Batich [2013] VSCA 53 considered a County Court case where the sentencing judge held he should refer an offence of glassing, charged as recklessly causing serious injury, back to the Magistrates' Court.Some indictable offences can be determined summarily, that is, before a court of summary jurisdiction, or before a trial court on indictment (Our …
Continue reading DPP v Batich [2013] VSCA 53 — summary determination of charges
Parliament introduced the Justice Legislation Amendment Bill 2013 last week.Part 6 of the Bill introduces perhaps the most significant amendment. It will overcome the effect of the decision in Brittain v Mansour [2013] VSC 50. That was the case which held charitable donations and the like were not valid as special conditions of adjourned undertakings imposed under …
Continue reading Justice Legislation Amendment Bill 2013: donations again available for undertakings
Shepherd & Anor v Kell & Anor [2013] VSC 24 was an application under s 85B of the Sentencing Act 1991 for a compensation order against two men convicted of manslaughter. The application was made by the victim's parents, who are recognised as victims of the crime themselves by the definition provided at s 3 …
Shepherd & Anor v Kell & Anor [2013] VSC 24 was an application under s 85B of the Sentencing Act 1991 for a compensation order against two men convicted of manslaughter. The application was made by the victim's parents, who are recognised as victims of the crime themselves by the definition provided at s 3 …