Singh v The Queen [2011] VSCA 263: when is a witness available?

DPP v Nicholls [2010] VSC 397 clarified that unavailable in relation to a witness means something more than just not in court. It was already apparent from the definition in the Dictionary of the Evidence Act 2008, but Nicholls confirmed it. What does available mean?Singh v The Queen [2011] VSCA 263 is an interlocutory, mid-trial …

Continue reading Singh v The Queen [2011] VSCA 263: when is a witness available?

Applying Verdins

Edit: In Abdifar v The Queen [2012] VSCA 66 the Court of Appeal rejected the notion that Verdins needs to be specifically referred to by the sentencing judge in order to find that the principles had been properly considered.It is true that his Honour did not explicitly mention the extent to which he thought that …

Continue reading Applying Verdins

DPP v Meade [2011] VSC 358: Why? Because he says so

It's now common for magistrates in traffic light and speeding cases to receive the whole of the prosecution's case in the form of documents authorised by statute.These 'certificates' may have a photograph in them but their real evidentiary value is contained at s 83A of the Road Safety Act 1986 which reads,83A. Evidence relating to …

Continue reading DPP v Meade [2011] VSC 358: Why? Because he says so

R v Carpenter [2011] ACTSC 71: Requirements of a valid identification

R v Carpenter [2011] ACTSC 71 involved a series of pre-trial rulings about the admissibility of identification evidence.Identification evidence means evidence that is—(a) an assertion by a person to the effect that a defendant was, or resembles (visually, aurally or otherwise) a person who was, present at or near a place where— (i) the offence …

Continue reading R v Carpenter [2011] ACTSC 71: Requirements of a valid identification

Director of Public Prosecutions v Finnegan [2011] TASCCA 3: proving a prior inconsistent statement

In DPP v Finnegan [2011] TASCCA 3 the Tasmanian Court of Criminal Appeal ruled the trial judge was wrong to refuse leave to the prosecution to cross-examine its own witness. Three men stood trial for assault. The Crown called a witness, Watkins, who had earlier pled guilty to his involvement. Watkins claimed no knowledge of …

Continue reading Director of Public Prosecutions v Finnegan [2011] TASCCA 3: proving a prior inconsistent statement