Last Friday the Supreme Court handed down DPP v Easwaralingam & Anor. The case was a request by the Director of Public Prosecutions for judicial review of the refusal by a magistrate to allow an adjournment sought by the prosecution, and refusing to allow the absent witness's statement to be tendered.The adjournment applicationThe accused faced …
Tag: evidence
DPP v Easwaralingam & Anor [2010] VSC 437: adjournment applications and unavailable witnesses
Last Friday the Supreme Court handed down DPP v Easwaralingam & Anor. The case was a request by the Director of Public Prosecutions for judicial review of the refusal by a magistrate to allow an adjournment sought by the prosecution, and refusing to allow the absent witness's statement to be tendered.The adjournment applicationThe accused faced …
Adjournment applications
Edit: The Court of Appeal strongly rejected the notion that adjournments are of an administrative character, and so attract human rights considerations, in Slaveski v The Queen (on the application of the Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of Victoria) [2012] VSCA 48.Redlich and Nettle JJA [at 106]: The Commission contended that, when a trial judge …
DPP v Nicholls [2010] VSC 397: Exempted witnesses are unavailable
Edit: Because of the case of DPP v Easwaralingam & Anor [2010] VSC 437 I've read through Darmody again recently. It is impossible to reconcile this magistrate's reasoning with the Court of Appeal's decision and the wording of cl 4(c) of Pt 2 the Dictionary of the Evidence Act 2008. In the pointed words of …
Continue reading DPP v Nicholls [2010] VSC 397: Exempted witnesses are unavailable
National scales and measurements
An unrepresented litigant suffers from all sorts of disadvantages in court proceedings. Not having a grasp of the relevant legal principles is just the start. From not knowing formal etiquette, to simply being nervous speaking publicly, there's a host of reasons why anyone would be better off getting a lawyer.There are two common tactical mistakes …