The Great Dissenter

Edit: For another perspective, here's an opinion piece written by the man who was responsible for choosing Michael Kirby for the job, former Attorney-General Michael Lavarch, writing in The Australian when Kirby stepped down in 2009. It's not very well-written but it does remark on some of the Great Dissenter's judicial accomplishments.Former Puisne High Court …

Continue reading The Great Dissenter

Programming note

Monday's Australian Story is about Nicholas Cowdery QC, the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions. The uncompromising DPP is about to retire after 17 years in the role.Pic: Kate Geraghty for the smhRichard Ackland recounts the fractious relationship between Cowdery and NSW Attorney-General John Hatzistergos in a 2009 piece for the Sydney Morning Herald here. Recent …

Continue reading Programming note

What should a modern court building look like?

Edit: The new Brisbane court complex is now open. I happily admit that it looks great from some angles.Today's Herald-Sun carries a contribution by Marilyn Warren to the paper's current Make Melbourne Better campaign.The article is an economical work of recycling by the Chief Justice. It's extracted from a much longer address made by her …

Continue reading What should a modern court building look like?

Community expectations

The Court of Appeal resentenced an offender for sexual penetration of a child in WCB v The Queen [2010] VSCA 230. The Court's own summary of the case can be read here.The offender had been sentenced to a non-parole period of six years, which was reduced to four. The case would be unremarkable but for …

Continue reading Community expectations

Bubble trouble

Edit: Contempt proceedings in Victorian courts are (fortunately) rare. One past instance is Anissa Pty Ltd v Parsons [1999] VSC 430. Cummins J's decision is interesting for the story it tells and the law it applies. A magistrate has imposed one month's imprisonment for contempt of court to an accused who blew and popped a …

Continue reading Bubble trouble