DPP v FG [2012] VSCA 84: all or nothing?

The Court of Appeal last week decided DPP v FG [2012] VSCA 85, which considered an unusual situation with a highly edited transcript and frequently un-transcribable recording, compounded by the loss of the recording when the appeal was heard.The original trial dealt with charges alleging sexual offences by the appellant against his natural son. Part …

Continue reading DPP v FG [2012] VSCA 84: all or nothing?

Cook v Commissioner of Police [2012] QCA 118: demerit disqualification a matter of law

We've previously discussed the sometimes-fine distinctions between errors of fact and errors of law. (In fact, when I look, we've covered it almost ad nauseam: Fishing for a fact? Ostrowski v Palmer; Mistake of fact or mistake of law? and Mistakes of fact, mistakes of law (revisited) are the main posts on the topic.)The Queensland …

Continue reading Cook v Commissioner of Police [2012] QCA 118: demerit disqualification a matter of law